Dear Cousin

by Ventureland

Category

True Crime

Frequency

Complete series

Language

English

Dear Cousin: The Stalking of Susan Fensten is the gripping true story of one woman's quest for long lost family. After the deaths of her sister and estranged father, Susan searches for relatives on an early online genealogy forum. When she meets cousins from her grandfather's other family, they're everything she'd hoped for—until it all goes to hell. Susan’s dreams are shattered when she learns her relatives’ dangerous history, and she is bombarded with threatening messages and sexually explicit...

Listen Ad-Free with Poddly

Poddly automatically skips ads in your favorite podcasts.

Recent Reviews

Dumb

Mukhtar smith•3/19/2026

Turned it off when she decided to go to the kink party

Get some therapy

Santqu•2/12/2026

I don’t normally write reviews but this story is ridiculous. How could anyone be this stupid. She continues to engage with these characters that are obviously made up. The interactions are so off the wall who could beside it and yet she continues to engage. Then the craziness continues when this delusional woman randomly agrees to go to kink fest with her alleged cousin stalker who has been sexualizing and stalking her. Who could possibly be this stupid. From the beginning two things are obvious, this is all one person and it’s obviously the weirdly interested neighbor and friend.

Woah

Natstan03•1/20/2026

She’s a really good narrator/ story teller……. It’s totally fed up but I had a feeling it was him but only because there are other stories like this now- I would of never thought it was him if I were her- so creepy

Absolutely Crazy

Andylynn2736•12/23/2025

Love this story and all the twists, truly feel bad for Susan.

Disappointing

TheRecruitBuyer•12/22/2025

Repetitive storytelling bores you over time. Narrator changed names to protect identities… but then changes the name of the convicted criminal which ruins credibility at worst, judgment at best