I Think Not!
536
Episodes
4.7 / 5
Rating

I Think Not!

by I Think Not!

Category
True Crime
Frequency
Updated Weekly
Language
English
From murder, to crooked cops to tax evasion and scams, the world of true crime TV is full of stuff that makes us scream “I Think Not!” If you liked the smash hit comedy podcast "Obsessed with Disappeared," you’ll love this new show from co-hosts and best friends Ellyn Marsh & Joey Taranto. Join Ellyn, Joey – and all the characters that live inside their gorgeous heads – for true stories and the campy television that covers them. Get ready to laugh, cry and think about true crime in a whole new w...

Listen Ad-Free with Poddly

Poddly automatically skips ads in your favorite podcasts.

Learn More
Poddly LogoListen on PoddlyApple Podcasts LogoApple PodcastsSpotify LogoSpotify

Recent Reviews

Toxic People!

long Island Pat•7/20/2026

Ellyn- I listened over the early catalog. You were/are amazing. Joey - awesome person and friend! I felt the pain and torture you endured all over again. P. was/is NO DB and was absolutely jealous and nasty. His crazy comes out strong and clear! I’m so glad that you got rid of the toxic men in your life!

I Think Yes!

chikirsten•7/9/2026

Joey and Ellyn are so fun to listen to. Their rapport is infectious. Next time they have a live show in my area, I’m going….cuz I need hugs…

TOO MANY ADS

j_a_x_•6/11/2026

Update: I love this show but the ads are making it unlistenable! And we get it, you haaaaaaate vegans 🙄 how dare they not participate in animal exploitation like you

Amazing

gabbydiane11•6/9/2026

Been listening for years and am a member of the Patreon. Ellyn and Joey are just rays of sunshine and I look forward to listening to them every week. I got to meet them after a tour show one night and they were just as sweet in person!

I think SO!

KeepOnSpraying•6/4/2026

Been listening for years and I’m truly OBSESSED! The laughs they provide are a welcomed escape and change to what’s going on. They address the subject matter in a fun way which makes me feel even better about being addicted to listening to so many different true crime / serial killer pods. Give them a chance … you won’t be disappointed!